Wishful Thinking Will Not Solve The Israel-Palestine Conflict

This article was originally published on Oct. 26, 2016 on the Huffington Post.


The appearance of B’Tselem Director Hagai El-Ad at the UN last week caused a healthy furor.  While European and other politicians supported his testimony, Israel’s right-wing leaders went so far as to accuse El-Ad of treason.  Yet this tiny Israeli human rights organization did what international diplomacy has failed to do for years: it held Israel to account – just briefly – for important violations of international law. 

El-Ad argued something that most Canadian politicians have thus far been unwilling to accept: that you can like Israel, yet still criticize it.  More importantly, El-Ad clearly implicated the international community in the resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.  “The occupation isn’t an internal Israeli issue, but a major international issue. There’s no such thing as a democratic occupation. This can’t be an [Israeli] internal matter.”

Canadian politicians should learn from B’Tselem.  Unfortunately, the only position that many Canadian politicians are comfortable with is something like: “We support an end to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through a negotiated two-state solution.”  Everyone’s comfortable with it: Trudeau’s Liberals, the Conservatives, the NDP and Canada’s Greens.  The problem is, it’s meaningless.

For the Canadian politicians who might’ve missed it, Israel withdrew from US-sponsored negotiations on April 24, 2014 – two and a half years ago.  And if that wasn’t convincing enough, Israel’s current PM Benjamin Netanyahu won re-election in 2015 based on the promise to never allow a Palestinian state in the West Bank. 

The logic is pretty simple: no negotiations – no negotiated solution.

The fact that every party across the Canadian political spectrum proclaims the same position was probably a tip-off that a commitment to a “negotiated solution” means little.  Sure, everyone wants peace – who doesn’t?  In parliamentary discussions earlier this year, it was amazing how many times words like “dialog” and “peace process” were bandied about.  But repeating platitudes which are detached from the day-to-day reality makes one naïve at best, and complicit at worst.

It’s a bit like commenting on a married couple who have severe marital problems, complete with shouting matches and physical abuse.  While all their friends may agree that the marriage is in trouble and that the couple should get counselling, no true friend would allow the husband to repeatedly beat his wife as they wait for counselling.  But Canadian political leaders seem perfectly willing to allow the “beating” to continue as they await the ever elusive negotiated solution (“counselling”) between Israel and Palestine. 

Brazilian philosopher Paolo Friere argued that, “Washing one's hands of the conflict between the powerful and the powerless means to side with the powerful, not to be neutral.”  Yet that is exactly what Canadian politicians do with each passing year as they smugly declare their devotion to the long-awaited “negotiated solution.” 

How to stop the beating?  Regardless of which side in the conflict they may favour, Canadian politicians could follow the simple example of B’Tselem from last week at the UN: hold human rights violators to account.

First, like B’Tselem, Canadian politicians must condemn Israeli settlement building: as frequently and forcefully as possible.  A form of colonization, settlements violate international law, and – according to chief Israeli negotiator Tzipi Livni – were the chief reason that negotiations failed in 2014. 

Beyond settlements, Canadian politicians should also be ready to condemn the other insidious on-the-ground realities of the conflict.  In recent months, Palestinian knife attacks on Israelis have been regularly reported in Canadian media, but only rarely do we hear of the hundreds of Palestinian political prisoners in Israeli jails, the Israeli demolition of Palestinian homes, or the onerous Israeli military restrictions on Palestinian movement around the West Bank and Gaza. 

Second, Canadian politicians must not hesitate to call out indiscriminate and disproportionate attacks from either side.  Canadian politicians already seem comfortable condemning Hamas rocket attacks from Gaza, but they must also be sure to condemn indiscriminate Israeli attacks.  In the 2014 Gaza flare-up, for example, 65% of Palestinian fatalities were civilians. 

Finally, Canadian politicians and parties should be prompt to call for a ceasefire the moment violence erupts between Israelis and Palestinians.  Not only is armed violence between states in violation of core precepts of the UN Charter, but the disproportionate victims of such aggression are inevitably civilians.  Beyond all logic, the Harper government repeatedly opposed international calls for ceasefires, as if the conflict could be assuaged by allowing either side to pursue its goals militarily. 

While these suggestions for Canadian politicians barely scratch the surface, they start to respond to B’Tselem’s assertion that the conflict is more than just an internal Israeli issue.  The whole world desires peace between Israelis and Palestinians, but only active engagement – not wishful thinking – will facilitate a solution.  In the meantime, Canadian politicians should do everything they can to stop the beating.



Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
Join the newsletter Donate

See other recent stories:

The Liberals’ Feminist Foreign Policy is not Compatible with “Business as Usual”

The Liberal Government's Troubled Relationship with the Rule of Law

Trudeau's "Feminism" Just Ain't Cutting It

Consultations On Islamophobia Are Not An Alternative To Action

The Conservatives' Jerusalem Promise Is Scheer Madness

In Case You Missed It, Parliament Issued Its M-103 Islamophobia Report

Is Singh’s NDP Prepared to Distinguish Itself?

When Will Canadians Get The Anti-Islamophobia Measures They Want?

Bill 62: Colonialism 101

Canada Must Learn From Past Arms Sales Folly

Israel is Being Singled Out – For Favouritism

Roger Waters' support For BDS strengthens his anti-war credibility

Israel's War Of Textbooks Comes to Canada

Give The Anti-Palestinian Rhetoric A Rest

Canada Must Do More Than Just Throw Money At Palestinian Refugees

UWO Rejects Pressure From Israeli Lobby Group Over UN Special Rapporteur

Whats Up With Treyf a Debatably Jewish Podcast

Canada's Flip-flop On West Bank Wines Betrays Canadian Consumers' Interests

Canada Now a Hawk On Nuclear Arms

Trudeau Government Blocks Direct Flights to Beirut

Niki Ashton represents new breed of Canadian leader

Abuse of Prisoners Is Intolerable, Whether in Palestine or Northern Ireland

Liberals Largely Insincere On Arms Trade Treaty Bill

Canadian Politicians Can’t Cherry Pick Malala Yousafzai’s Message

Dysfunction at the UN: The Saudis aren’t the only ones to blame

50 Years Of Israeli Occupation Is Far Too Long

Trudeau’s Simplistic Approach Won’t Work In Syria

Canadian Zionists Join World Wide Campaign to Mark Centenary of Balfour Declaration

Trudeau Must Not Rubber Stamp Trump’s Military Interventions

NDP Leaders Race Should Be About Who Can Beat Trudeau