This article was originally published on August 28, 2017 on Huffington Post Canada.
Last Thursday, the Trudeau government announced another $25 million in aid to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), the UN aid agency for Palestinian refugees. Within hours, Canadian pro-Israel lobby groups had criticized the decision, dredging up spurious arguments to subvert any potential public sympathy for Palestinians, refugees or otherwise. But average Canadians can reasonably be excused for asking, "Why should Canada support Palestinian refugees?"
Canadians should also be interested to note that no UN member states situated close to Palestine supported the partition: Turkey, Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Iraq and Iran all opposed it.
The repatriation of Palestinian refugees would mean that they would return to homes and land in Israel — an option which has been anathema to every successive Israeli government since 1948. Right or wrong, since its founding, Israel has never allowedPalestinian refugees to return legally.
The integration of Palestinian refugees today into their host countries has not been an option either. Millions of these refugees live in Lebanon, Jordan and Syria, but these countries have no motive to absolve Israel and the west of their accountability for Palestinian refugees. Legally and politically speaking, there's no reason these countries need to provide a long-term solution to the Palestinian refugees who surged over their borders in the late 1940s.
Conditions for Palestinian refugees in these countries vary somewhat, but most refugees face huge challenges — often formal legal obstacles — to enjoying their civil liberties, entering their profession of choice, travelling as they wish, living where they want, and more. Refugees in Gaza and the West Bank face fewer issues, but remain among the poorest in these territories.
One could argue that such countries should accept Palestinian refugees on humanitarian grounds and offer them citizenship. But the same could be said for Israel: that's where the refugees' homes are.
The third possible solution — resettlement of Palestinian refugees to third countries like Canada — accommodates only a trickle, and will never make a dent in the overall numbers.
Facing the dilemma of Palestinian refugees, the international community created UNRWA, and the agency began operations in 1950. Given the absence of solutions for Palestinian refugees, many remain under the care of UNRWA. The agency does its own fundraising, and continues operations through the generosity of governments around the world. The U.S., the EU and Saudi Arabia provided over half of UNRWA's funds of $1.2 billion in 2016. Canada's contribution of $25 million represented only about 1.5 percent of the agency's 2016 budget.
70 years is a long time for 700,000 people and their descendants to live as refugees. During these 70 years, refugees in places all around the world have fled their homes, and been repatriated and/or resettled: refugees from the 1973 South Africa-Namibian war; refugees from the 1983 clash between Greek and Turkish Cypriots; refugees from Bosnia and Kosovo from the war in the early 1990s; and elsewhere.
But unlike these other conflicts, the world seems powerless or unwilling to address the challenge of Palestinian refugees. While Palestinian refugees wait for decades in overcrowded and underserviced camps, Canada and the west continue to apply band-aids to the crisis. Like 2016, and now 2017, Canada and other Western countries cough up funds annually, seemingly in the hopes that the Palestinian refugee crisis will magically go away. But it will not.
Honestly, Canada shouldn't still be supporting Palestinian refugees: they should have had their status resolved decades ago. Canada — especially as gavel-holder for the UN refugee working group — should have been working diligently with international partners to ensure a peace agreement long ago between Israel and the Palestinians. Rather than applying palliative annual aid packages to impoverished Palestinians, the Trudeau government and its western allies must compel Israel to accept a peace agreement which respects the legitimate rights and grievances of the Palestinians.
Otherwise, one day a few years from now, we may find ourselves observing that Syrian refugees fled their country's civil war, but were later repatriated and resettled — while Palestinian refugees still languish in refugee camps.
Be the first to comment
Sign in with